NewsLine Philippines

Building Information Highway for the Community

Davao court recognizes Magno, dismisses Acosta’s “Quo Warranto” case

by 121 Comments

DAVAO CITY, Philippines — The Regional Trial Court (RTC) has ruled in favor of Leo Magno, recognizing his appointment as the legal Chairperson of the Mindanao Development Authority (MinDA) and dismissing the claim of ousted chair Maria Belen Sunga Acosta.

“Undoubtedly, this petition must be dismissed not only on the ground that it is an improper remedy as it is not anchored on the respondent’s qualification but more so on the premise that it is a challenge against an act of the President who is immune from suit, even without him invoking the privilege,” cited the two-page decision rendered by RTC Branch 15 presiding judge Mario C. Duaves on May 27, 2024.

Newsline Philippines secured a copy of the decision after submitting a formal request, which the court favored.

Acosta had filed a quo warranto case against Magno, docketed as Special Civil Action R-DVO-24-02664, which was heard by Judge Duaves. In her petition, Acosta sought to restrain Magno from entering the MinDA office and prayed for the issuance of a “Status quo ante” order to prevent Magno from interfering, disturbing, or disrupting her from performing her duties for the remainder of her term.

Acosta invoked Republic Act No. 9996, or the Mindanao Development Authority Act of 2010. Section 3 of the Act states that MinDA “shall promote, coordinate and facilitate the active and extensive participation of all sectors to effect the socioeconomic development of Mindanao.” Section 7 of the Act states that the Chairperson “shall serve a term of six (6) years from the date of his/her appointment, unless removed for cause.”

Judge Duaves also cited the case of Esmero vs. Duterte (G.R. No. 256288, June 29, 2021), where the Supreme Court en banc dismissed the petition “For utter lack of merit.”

“Our ruling in De Lima v. Duterte is clear: the President is immune from suit during his incumbency, regardless of the nature of the suit filed against him. Petitioner named President Duterte as the sole respondent in this case. For this reason, this suit should be dismissed outright,” the decision added.

“Even if, for the sake of argument, the Court was inclined to overlook this fatal flaw and consider the case filed against the Executive Secretary as the representative of the President, if only to save the petition from perfunctory dismissal, a writ of mandamus would still not lie in petitioner’s favor,” the decision continued.

A quo warranto case is a legal proceeding during which an individual’s right to hold an office or governmental privilege is challenged. The term “quo warranto” is Latin for “by what authority” and the case typically questions the legality of a person’s claim to a public office or authority.-Editha Z. Caduaya

About Editha Z. Caduaya

Edith Z Caduaya studied Bachelor of Science in Development Communication at the University of Southern Mindanao.

The chairperson of Mindanao Independent Press Council (MIPC) Inc.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. xulrgamzo says

    Wybór odpowiednich okien do domu pasywnego to kluczowy element wpływający na komfort życia, koszty eksploatacji oraz ekologiczność budynku. W dobie rosnącej świadomości ekologicznej i potrzeby oszczędzania energii, warto zwrócić uwagę na nowoczesne rozwiązania dostępne na rynku. Jednym z wiodących producentów okien, który doskonale wpisuje się w wymagania domów pasywnych, jest firma Drutex. W niniejszym artykule Gra Aviator oferuje kilka form bonusów, w tym darmowe spiny i zakłady automatyczne. Dodatkowo w grze dostępny jest czat, który umożliwia graczom interakcję i dzielenie się wskazówkami w kasynie aviator w sekcji gier awaryjnych. Gra Awiator na pieniądze została uznana za jedną z najpopularniejszych w 2021 roku przez kasyna online 1win i 1xBet. Rejestracja w różnych kasynach online w Aviator to prosty proces, który otwiera wiele możliwości gry. Postępując zgodnie z instrukcjami rejestracji, możesz utworzyć konto i grać na pieniądze w automacie Scribe w kasynach takich jak Pin Up, Parimatch, 1xBet, 1win, Mostbet.
    https://doodleordie.com/profile/orcajuska1989
    Alışveriş sepetinizde hiç ürün yok Rất tiếc, sản phẩm này hiện không tồn tại. Hãy chọn một phương thức kết hợp khác. Jednym z najważniejszych aspektów każdej platformy inwestycyjnej jest dostępność i jakość wsparcia klienta. Betonred to miejsce, gdzie zespół profesjonalistów służy pomocą 24 7. Dzięki szerokiemu zakresowi dostępnych kanałów kontaktowych, użytkownicy mogą łatwo uzyskać wsparcie w razie jakichkolwiek problemów. Bônus de 100$ no marjack bet – marjackbet-br: Faça Seu Cadastro Agora Mesmo! Mines to ulubiona gra wśród peruwiańskich graczy. Kasyna lubią Betano e Brabet należą do najpopularniejszych, ale istnieją inne, dobrze oceniane opcje, które również oferują tę grę, zapewniając bezpieczną i ekscytującą rozgrywkę z różnymi możliwościami bonusowymi i promocjami:

    Reply

  2. ztdcftryz says

    Plik SH1e7eb130f4719dff5bfab9d8bc1bb17243759f3da Tzw. „Hack Gry Aviator” to oszukańczy program, który twierdzi, że potrafi zhakować grę Aviator. To nieprawda. Unikaj kupowania podejrzanych aplikacji lub płacenia za dostęp do prywatnych usług czy społeczności, które obiecują gwarantowane przewidywania wyników gier crash. Te oszustwa często kończą się kradzieżą funduszy i danych osobowych. Recenzje klientów, w tym oceny produktu w postaci gwiazdek, pomagają klientom dowiedzieć się więcej o produkcie i zdecydować, czy jest dla nich odpowiedni. Aviatrix to kolejna ekscytująca gra crash, podobna do Aviator, w której runda kończy się nie wtedy, gdy samolot znika z ekranu, ale gdy eksploduje. Gra oferuje dynamiczną rozgrywkę z wieloma interesującymi funkcjami, które przyciągają entuzjastów hazardu.
    https://v.gd/vTXpv8
    Dive into the excitement with Dabet, where every bet brings you closer to big wins. Their modern platform and real-time updates keep you ahead of the game. betabuys.uk Dive into the excitement with Dabet, where every bet brings you closer to big wins. Their modern platform and real-time updates keep you ahead of the game. betabuys.uk Here’s what makes the Most bet APK a must-have for any mobile bettor: mostbet az giriş mostbet3043.ru . Here is my web-site 28BET (28bet338) mostbet uz apk mostbet3030.ru . The Melbet promo code 2025: MEGA200. New players can get 100 welcome bonus up to 130$ when registering a new account. Melbet offers its players the opportunity to bet on major sporting events, as well as high payout slots at any time. To get extra money for the next bet, it is enough to use Melbet promo code. You can find it on our website. We regularly update the data on bonuses and combinations that can be used when registering or depositing.

    Reply

  3. yehpiorem says

    La primul depozit după înregistrare Deși nicio strategie nu poate garanta o victorie, activează LuckyJet jucătorii au o serie de trucuri pe care le folosesc. 1Win este o casă de pariuri online autorizată și fiabilă, care este lider pe piața jocurilor de noroc din 2018. Jucătorii noi pot obține un bonus generos de 500% la primele lor depuneri, după care pot beneficia de alte oferte de bonus și alte privilegii ale site-ului. Înscrieți-vă astăzi pentru a începe să pariați pe evenimentele sportive preferate la 1Win Moldova. Pentru a descărca și instala LuckyJet Signals Telegram Bot, urmați acești pași simpli: 30% cashback la pierderi în fiecare săptămână! Jucătorii nu ar trebui să riște mai mult decât își permit să piardă și ar trebui să ia pauze pentru a evita dependența. Cu răbdare și abilități de observație, LuckyJet poate fi un joc distractiv și potențial profitabil.
    https://roomstyler.com/users/httpsbaltine
    Nu există probleme cu depunerea și retragerea, 1WIN își prețuiește reputația și a fi onest este benefic pentru toată lumea pe termen lung. Win-Win. Norocos Jet 1Win este un joc accident la comandă dezvoltat de Gaming Corps, care este disponibil exclusiv pe 1Win platforma de cazinou. O componentă esențială pentru o experiență de joc plăcută și sigură la LuckyJet este reprezentată de serviciile de asistență pentru clienți oferite de 1Win. Platforma pune la dispoziție multiple canale de comunicare, precum chat live, email sau chiar apeluri telefonice, pentru a răspunde prompt la orice întrebări sau dificultăți întâmpinate de jucători. Noul Lucky Jet este cea mai recentă versiune a avionului de epocă realizată de cazinoul online 1win, o firmă de jocuri de noroc fondată în 2014. Aceștia au mai multe aparate de sloturi, jocuri cu multiplicatori și alte lucruri interesante pe drum.

    Reply

  4. hefalkjca says

    For relatively low values of Q, the cavity regime occurred, as the upward water jet kept confined in the sand bed (h H). For the latter case, the mean upward water velocity at the sand-water interface (u) was measured with an electromagnetic propeller anemometer (Omni Instruments, MiniWater20). A simple equation was derived to predict the real-scale leakage flow rate from upward water jets bursting at the ground. The results provided in this study will potentially help water utilities quantify the water loss from pipe bursts. A simple equation was derived to predict the real-scale leakage flow rate from upward water jets bursting at the ground. The results provided in this study will potentially help water utilities quantify the water loss from pipe bursts.
    https://nkcommerce.com/baby/guia-completo-para-jogar-lucky-jet-no-1win-o-jogo-de-cassino-online-para-jogadores-do-brasil/
    Provavelmente, você já se perguntou o que é Brazino 777?! Este é um renomado casino online que transcende a simples prática de jogo, imergindo os jogadores em um universo de adrenalina e emoção. Aliás, no epicentro dessa jornada de entretenimento, destacam-se os envolventes “crash games”. Estes não são apenas jogos de azar; são experimentos emocionantes que desafiam os limites da sorte. Nessa modalidade, você pode experimentar todos os recursos desse crash game, desde os multiplicadores até as apostas simultâneas Como já falamos, a Roleta é um dos destaques. Mas há mesas de Bacará, Blackjack (o famoso 21), Poker e games shows, como Monopoly. Além de várias mesas exclusivas, a bet365 também traz opções em português, dedicadas aos jogadores brasileiros.

    Reply

  5. qennvyixk says

    The circumstances of colour prediction game earn money has seen a surge in popularity for color prediction games, often referred to as color trading. These games present players with the exciting challenge of predicting the outcome of color-based events, typically involving betting on colors like red or green. The allure of potential winnings and the simplicity of gameplay have contributed to the widespread appeal of color trading apps. However, it’s important to exercise caution and conduct thorough research before engaging in any online gambling activity, including color prediction games. You get 4 games in our color prediction game software. 1.WINGO 2.K3 LOTTERY 3. 5D LOTTERY and AVITOR Game. Wingo Color Prediction Game is an easy and fun online game where you can win money by guessing colors. The idea is simple: pick the right color from the given options in each round. This game has quickly become popular in India because it’s not only enjoyable but also gives players a chance to earn cash.
    https://rawaqs.org/2025/06/03/why-the-american-aviator-game-has-a-cult-following/
    In Softonic we scan all the files hosted on our platform to assess and avoid any potential harm for your device. Our team performs checks each time a new file is uploaded and periodically reviews files to confirm or update their status. This comprehensive process allows us to set a status for any downloadable file as follows: TeenPatti.pk is an independent product reviews, brand reviews and news site for Teen Patti players in Pakistan. Created by a team of online slots experts, Teenpatti.pk contains all the information you need to enjoy an exciting, fair and safe gaming experience on 3 Patti sites and apps. Links to third party sites on Teenpatti.pk are provided for informational and educational purposes only. If you use these links, you will leave this site. Have you tried Dragon Tiger Slots – Up Down? Be the first to leave your opinion!

    Reply

  6. isjxenhmj says

    Para entender como ganar en Lucky Jet, puedes estudiar estas estrategias: Regístrate, haz un depósito y comienza tu viaje en Lucky Jet 1win con un gran bono de bienvenida de hasta $12.631.000. Aquí te estamos sugiriendo diferentes estrategias de juego que puedes seguir en Lucky Jet. La idea es que te quedes solo con aquellas que te funcionen a ti, a tu forma de jugar. Lucky Jet es un juego en línea proporcionado por 1WIN games pero completamente desarrollado por 1WIN Games y lanzado en 2021. El juego rápidamente ganó popularidad debido a su jugabilidad dinámica y emocionante, atrayendo tanto a nuevos jugadores como a experimentados. En Lucky Jet, los jugadores necesitan realizar apuestas y retirar ganancias antes de que el héroe del juego, Joe, se vaya volando. Lucky Jet procesará su solicitud de retirada y le enviará el dinero al método de pago elegido en un plazo de 24 horas.
    https://sfgym24h.com/de-viral-a-rentable-el-ascenso-del-juego-de-inflar-globos/
    Δdocument.getElementById(“ak_js_1”).setAttribute(“value”,(new Date()).getTime()); Como tal, los símbolos especiales no existen dentro de este mundo innovador de la combinación del deporte y los juegos de apuesta online. No obstante, puedes guiarte de los símbolos de acumulación que aparecen en la parte superior de penalty shoot. Esto es un marcador que ayuda a guiarte según los multiplicadores que vayas cogiendo a lo largo de la tanda de penaltis. Apps & Games NEWHelp Scout, Freshdesk, Zendesk & More: Train Your Chatbot with Real Support Tickets → In other words, in the event of a draw, the winner of the tie will be the team who finished highest in the league standings at the end of the season, with there being no need for a penalty shootout to determine the winner. The match eventually went to penalties, with Peña saving four to give Barça B a real chance of progress but they missed too many, with Konrad, Peque, Manaj, Busquets and Mingo all missing.

    Reply

  7. xcjkuoozn says

    Este site é destinado a maiores de 18 anos. Jogue com responsabilidade. Apostas são atividades com riscos de perdas financeiras. Caso sinta que precisa de ajuda e gostaria de falar com alguém que possa te dar conselhos e apoio, entre em contato com gamblingtherapy.org pt-br , jogadoresanonimos.br ou ibjr.org . Na minha análise, encontrei todos os principais esportes além do futebol, o que inclui basquete, vôlei, tênis de mesa, etc. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. O cassino também merece destaque, principalmente porque oferece uma diversidade interessante de partidas de Poker ao vivo. O cassino online Sportingbet conta com diversas vantagens para os jogadores brasileiros, incluindo:
    https://devring.co.uk/aviator-jogo-de-aposta-entenda-a-dinamica-e-os-riscos-envolvidos/
    Já existem duas versões do Aviator na vitrine dos cassinos virtuais. O segundo surgiu em 2021 e recebeu um design atualizado e um gerador de números aleatórios. A mecânica continua a mesma. Esports ou esportes digitais são uma forma de videogame competitivo em que pessoas ou equipes competem contra todas as diferenças em diversos videogames. Os esportes eletrônicos ganharam reputação mundial nos últimos anos, e a base de fãs está crescendo rapidamente. Parimatch oferece a oportunidade de competir contra diferentes jogadores ou em ligas especializadas organizadas. Os prêmios são enormes, e as ocasiões estão abertas a absolutamente todos. Os principais títulos do site são: O site da Parimatch é seguro e oferece exemplos de que facilitam navegação na plataforma. Quem é cliente Parimatch sabe que ao em vez do site oferecer apenas um modo de lazer bem feito, ele oferece tudo que promete. O apostador tem uma experiência muito fluída na Parimatch um fator que faz valer muito a pena ter uma conta na plataforma.

    Reply

  8. xlriamxdb says

    At some casinos, like social casinos, this is possible. Most sites that offer free games do not offer real money prizes on free games. At SlotoCash, playing real money slot games could significantly increase your winnings with just one spin. Our slots are designed with varying levels of volatility, ensuring a range of payout opportunities from regular small wins to massive jackpots. Each spin offers a chance to win big and transform your gaming experience. Check out our wide selection of slot games and see if you can be our next big winner Although DraftKings Casino offers the lowest number of slots on this list (500+), the good news is that you can play over 40 DraftKings exclusives. This includes titles like NBA Slam Dunk Roulette, Playboy Diamonds, and Loki’s Luck. The casino’s slot collection covers all themes and slot types—for instance, a quick search of Buffalo-themed slots found over 18 titles, including Buffalo Blitz II. You can also enjoy 60+ Megaways slots.
    https://exam.ecic.edu.pk/aviator-slots-should-you-trust-the-hype/
    Many of the best NextGen slots are available in several variations which is proof of how fast they became some of the provider’s most popular games. Almost a year after being released, these NextGen casino slots offer all you need for a wonderful gambling experience with modern sounds, colourful scenes and plenty of wilds. Wonder Hounds leads the list and of course, it is not a complete list. Please, refer to the software developer’s official website for more details onto the newest and upcoming slots. They mandate encryption to ensure real money online casinos protect your money and personal information. Plus, they vet the staff and test every game. Another way you can tell an online casino is safe and secure is if its website bears the relevant state board’s seal of approval.

    Reply

  12. Rodneymen says

    cheap erection pills [url=http://eropharmfast.com/#]ed medicines online[/url] online ed medication

    Reply

  15. Rodneymen says

    pharmacy online australia [url=https://pharmau24.com/#]Buy medicine online Australia[/url] Online drugstore Australia

    Reply

  22. Rodneymen says

    get antibiotics quickly [url=http://biotpharm.com/#]buy antibiotics online uk[/url] buy antibiotics

    Reply

  27. Rodneymen says

    affordable ed medication [url=https://eropharmfast.shop/#]Ero Pharm Fast[/url] how to get ed meds online

    Reply

  90. Michaelsep says

    legal to buy prescription drugs from canada [url=https://expressrxcanada.com/#]Generic drugs from Canada[/url] prescription drugs canada buy online

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *