Escudero draws line: Duterte faces unexplained wealth allegations, not money laundering charge

Date:

Share post:

Senate impeachment court clarifies scope of allegations as prosecution questions relevance of defense financial investigator

MANILA  (November 20) — Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team does not have to defend her against a money laundering charge that is not before the Senate impeachment court, Presiding Officer Francis Escudero clarified Thursday, drawing a distinction between alleged unexplained wealth and criminal liability under anti-money laundering laws.

Escudero issued the clarification after House prosecution counsel Chel Diokno challenged the relevance of testimony from defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a lawyer and former financial investigator of the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC).

“He (Defense counsel Mark Vinluan) does not need to defend his client against a charge of violation of the Anti-Money Laundering Law. There is no such charge, but the AMLC was used as a basis to prove unexplained wealth,” Escudero said.

Diokno argued that Duterte was not facing a money laundering charge and that the impeachment proceedings centered on allegations of unexplained wealth, failure to declare assets and liabilities in her Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN), and participation in business.

He questioned whether Dela Fuente’s experience as a financial investigator qualified him to testify on those matters.

“The issues before this court are all centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of SALN, and participation in business. And I haven’t heard anything from this witness that would qualify him on those matters,” Diokno said.

Defense counsel Mark Vinluan disputed the objection, citing Page 14 of the Articles of Impeachment, which states that bank transactions involving Duterte and her husband “may have been involved in predicate offenses of money laundering.”

Vinluan then asked Dela Fuente, based on his financial investigation experience, about the importance of establishing certainty before accusing individuals of unlawful activity or money laundering.

Diokno objected, arguing that the reference to transactions that “may have been involved in predicate offenses” did not amount to a substantive money laundering charge before the impeachment court.

“The question is an attempt to mislead not only this court but to the public as well,” Diokno said.

Escudero allowed the defense to continue questioning the witness, noting that the prosecution itself had presented AMLC testimony and documents in support of Article II of the impeachment complaint.

However, he clarified that Dela Fuente’s qualification as an expert would be limited to offering opinions on AMLC documents.

Distinguishing financial evidence from criminal charges

The exchange highlights an important distinction in the impeachment proceedings: financial records and AMLC findings may be presented as evidence supporting allegations of unexplained wealth, but their use does not automatically mean the respondent is facing a separate criminal prosecution for money laundering.

The distinction matters because the Senate impeachment court must determine the allegations contained in the Articles of Impeachment, rather than treat every reference to a possible financial offense as a separate charge.

The proceedings also underscored the continuing disagreement between the prosecution and defense over the relevance, scope and interpretation of financial evidence.

During the hearing, the defense presented video recordings from the 2012 impeachment trial of former Chief Justice Renato Corona, including statements by the late Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago and Corona’s testimony before the Senate.

The defense used the recordings to advance its arguments before the impeachment court.

As the proceedings continue, the central question remains whether the evidence presented can substantiate the allegations involving Duterte’s wealth, financial disclosures and business interests.

For the public, the distinction is crucial: an allegation of unexplained wealth is not itself a money laundering conviction, and references to possible predicate offenses do not automatically establish criminal guilt.

RIZAL MEMORIAL COLLEGEspot_img

Related articles

Air Niugini Boeing 767 Makes Emergency Landing In Davao; All 146 On Board Safe

DAVAO CITY (November 21) — An international passenger flight bound for Papua New Guinea was forced to...

A Better Chance For Every Child: Marcos Signs Law Expanding Education Vouchers For Poor Students

DAVAO CITY (November 20) -For a child from a poor family, the dream of attending a good school...

PJ Simon: The Scoring Apostle Who Never Forgot Where He Came From

DAVAO CITY — Before he became the “Scoring Apostle,” before the championships, the All-Star selections, and the roar...

Shortened FPIC process puts Lumad ancestral lands at risk, rights groups warn

Indigenous leaders, Church groups question NCIP rules allowing faster project approvals, warning that weakened safeguards could expose communities...